The first concerns a KC fake punt on 4th-and-1 from their own 45-yard line in the 3rd quarter. Long-snapper James Winchester snapped the ball directly to punt protector Albert Wilson, who proceeded to take the ball 55 yards for a touchdown.
The second concerns the game-sealing pick-two runback of a two-point conversion try by Eric Berry near the end of the game.
For both of these plays, the question is: how many points should the Chiefs DST get, and did ESPN score the plays correctly?
First, the fake punt. The correct scoring for this play is that the DST should get 0 points, and ESPN scored it correctly. The reasoning is that a fake punt or fake field goal is no different from a team deciding to go for it on fourth down. In fact, when a team decides to run a fake punt/fake field goal, they have *clearly* decided to go for it on fourth down --- they're just hiding that fact from their opponent. So even though the punting unit is on the field, scoring a TD on a fake punt (or fake field goal) is no different from the QB throwing a TD on fourth down. It's still properly scored as points for the offense, not the DST.
(Things get complicated if there's ever a fumble on a punt, or a blocked field goal. If there's ever a change of possession, then for fantasy purposes BOTH teams are considered DST --- even if Drew Brees throws an interception, and the intercepting player fumbles, and then a Saints WR picks up the fumble and returns it for a score. In such a scenario, that's scored as a TD for the Saints DST [and the Saints WR, of course], even though their offense is on the field. The same principle applies for blocked kicks/punts or fumbles of a punt/kickoff return.)
The case of the pick-two is a bit murkier. Logic tells you that the DST should get 2 points for an interception, and 2 points for the conversion at the end of the return. However, the NFL does not consider the 'interception' of a 2-point conversion try to be a real interception. See Matt Ryan's stat line for the game from NFL.com:
The one interception listed here is from the pick-6 Berry returned earlier in the game. So if the NFL doesn't count an interception of a 2-point conversion attempt as a 'real' interception, then neither does ESPN, and neither will we.
However, the KC DST DOES deserve an additional 2 points, since Berry returned the conversion attempt and scored 2 points for his team (Meachem Rule). So I will add 2 points to the Chiefs DST for this week, and then I'll try to remember to adjust the league scoring so that such scores are automatically in the future.
No comments:
Post a Comment